Ask for an identity, connect a description, or recognize a conversational challenge.
A person position, an identity
A person position, an identity
The asker wants to know which person is meant.
who
The middle person identifies themself.
Who focuses the question on a person’s identity.
Who asks for a person’s identity; here one person identifies themself.
A sentence has a place referring to a person. Who lets us ask which person fills that place, or link the person to a further description.
The sketch focuses on identity reference, not physical movement. Relative who can refer to an already known person; rhetorical questions may not seek any identity at all.
Who /huː/ centres attention on a person or people. In a question, their identity may be missing. In a relative clause, who connects a person to a description. The same spelling therefore does more than ask “which person?”
Use the diagram as a reminder of a person position linked to an identity. It is a teaching model, not a claim about what every native speaker pictures. Grammar and the full expression determine the actual meaning.
01
Ask about a person
Find the person position first. Who may ask for an identity, fill a subject or object position, or introduce an embedded question.
01
who + be + identifying expression; Who?; Guess who + clause
Who is that?
ask for a person’s identity or role
Situation
You notice someone at the entrance.
What you communicate
You ask how to identify that person.
Who asks about people; the answer can be a name, relationship, or role.
Who is that? might be answered with a name or with That’s our new manager. Who is in charge? asks which person has a role. The missing information is an identity, not necessarily a name.
A short Who? asks for an identity without repeating the sentence: “Someone called.” “Who?” Guess who called! invites the listener to guess the person. Who can refer to one person or several; context supplies the number.
Use which person or which of you to make a limited choice explicit. Who stands on its own: say Which teacher called?, not Who teacher called?
Original example
Who is the person checking tickets at the door?
Watch the difference Who are you? can sound abrupt when said directly to a stranger. Could I have your name, please? is often friendlier.
02
who + verb phrase; who + auxiliary / modal + rest of verb phrase
Who called?
ask which person is the subject
Situation
A call arrived, but you do not know the caller.
What you communicate
You ask for the caller’s identity.
Who itself fills the subject position; there is no second subject.
Start with Someone called and replace Someone with Who: Who called? In an ordinary affirmative subject question, do not add do, does, or did just to mark the question. Who wants a seat? usually has singular wants even if several people may answer.
Keep auxiliaries that the verb phrase needs: Who can help? and Who has arrived? A negative can use do: Who didn’t get a ticket? Emphatic Who did call? is also possible when correcting an assumption.
Subject does not always mean the person performing an action. In Who was invited?, who is the grammatical subject of a passive verb and names the invited person.
Original example
Who sent the revised timetable?
Watch the difference For a neutral question, use Who sent it?, not Who did sent it? After did, a verb would have its base form.
03
who + do / does / did + subject + base verb; who + auxiliary / modal + subject + verb
Who did you call?
ask which person receives or is involved in an action
Situation
You know that your colleague made a call.
What you communicate
You ask which person your colleague called.
You is the subject; who asks for the missing object.
You called someone becomes Who did you call? In a simple present or past object question, put do, does, or did before the subject and use the base form of the main verb.
With an existing auxiliary, use that auxiliary: Who have you invited? With a modal, say Who can we ask? Compare Who called you? The two questions put the unknown person in different grammatical positions.
Whom did you call? is a formal alternative. Ordinary conversation usually uses who as an object; whom is not a general replacement for who in subject questions.
Original example
Who did you call about the broken lift?
Watch the difference Do not keep the past ending after did: Who did you call?, not Who did you called?
The preposition states the relationship; who supplies the person.
In everyday questions, a preposition often stays at the end: Who are you waiting for? Who did you travel with? Who is this message from? Changing for, with, or from changes the relationship, not the basic person reference of who.
Formal English can move the preposition forward and use whom: With whom did you travel? Prefer whom immediately after a fronted preposition in careful formal writing. The everyday version with who and a final preposition is natural.
The same choice occurs in relative clauses: the colleague who I work with; more formally, the colleague with whom I work. Who plus a preposition is not a phrasal verb family.
Original example
Who are you saving this seat for?
Watch the difference Do not drop a preposition required by the expression: Who are you waiting for?, not Who are you waiting?
05
know / ask / wonder + who + statement-order clause; who + to-infinitive
Do you know who she is?
put an identity question inside another clause
Situation
You want help identifying a visitor.
What you communicate
You ask whether another person knows the answer.
Inside the who-clause, use statement order rather than direct-question inversion.
Compare Who is she? with Do you know who she is? The outer question has Do you know; the inner clause keeps she before is. I wonder who she is and Tell me who she is use the same inner order without making the whole sentence a direct question.
When who is the inner subject, the order may look unchanged: I don’t know who called. With an object, remove question-only do: I know who you called, not I know who did you call.
An infinitive can express a choice of action: I don’t know who to ask means I cannot decide which person I should ask. It does not mean I cannot identify a person who already asked.
Original example
Could you tell me who the new coordinator is?
Watch the difference When embedding Who is she?, write who she is, not who is she. But who can itself be the inner subject: Tell me who is in charge is grammatical. A sequence beginning who is is not automatically wrong.
06
who + do you think / suppose + clause with a person position left open
Who do you think called?
ask for an opinion about someone’s identity
Situation
Someone called, and your friend may have a guess.
What you communicate
You ask who your friend thinks it was.
Who belongs to the inner situation; do you think introduces the opinion.
Start with You think someone called. To ask for that person’s identity, say Who do you think called? The unknown person is the subject of called, while you is the subject of think.
If the unknown person is an object, keep the inner subject: Who do you think Maya called? This asks for Maya’s contact. Who do you think called Maya? asks for the caller. The position of Maya makes the difference.
This is an information question about an opinion. The angry expression Who do you think you are? has a separate conversational function, explained later.
Original example
Who do you think left this note?
Watch the difference Do not add a duplicate subject: Who do you think left it?, not Who do you think he left it?
02
Link a person to a description
A relative who-clause identifies people or adds information about them. It does not ask a question, and its grammar depends on the role who plays inside the clause.
07
person / people + who + verb phrase
the person who called
identify a person by what they do
Situation
Several people could be meant.
What you communicate
A relative clause tells the listener which person you mean.
Who links a person to a description and serves as the relative clause’s subject.
In the person who called, the clause who called describes person. It is not asking a question. Who fills the subject position in that clause, so do not add he or she after it.
In a defining relative clause, that can often replace who: the person that called. Who is a clear choice for people. For ordinary objects, use which or that: a device that records sound.
Agreement follows the person or people described: a nurse who works nights, nurses who work nights. Who does not force every relative clause into the singular.
Original example
The neighbour who waters our plants is away this week.
Watch the difference Keep subject who: The neighbour who waters our plants…, not The neighbour waters our plants is away….
08
person + (who / that / whom) + subject + verb
the person (who) I called
identify a person through someone else’s action
Situation
You have spoken to one of the technicians.
What you communicate
You describe that technician by your earlier call.
I is the relative clause’s subject; who stands for its object.
The technician who I called means I called that technician. In this defining relative clause, who may be replaced by that or formal whom, or omitted: the technician I called.
The omission works because the person position is an object. Compare the technician who called me: who is the subject there and cannot simply disappear.
Do not fill the object position twice. The technician who I called him incorrectly adds him to a position already represented by who.
Original example
The technician I called yesterday has sent a quote.
Watch the difference Omitting who is a defining-relative option, not a rule for every clause containing who.
09
identified person, who + relative clause, + continuation
Maya, who lives nearby, …
add information about an already identified person
Situation
The listener knows which Maya you mean.
What you communicate
You add where she lives while reporting another fact.
Commas mark extra information rather than an identity restriction.
Maya, who lives nearby, can collect the keys identifies Maya by name and adds a separate fact. In writing, place commas around this non-defining clause when the sentence continues after it.
Keep who in this kind of clause, even when it is an object: Maya, who we invited yesterday, has replied. Formal whom is possible for an object. Do not replace who with that or leave it out here.
Compare My sister who lives nearby can help, which identifies which sister, with My sister, who lives nearby, can help, which adds information about an already identified sister. Context determines which meaning is intended.
Original example
Maya, who lives nearby, can collect the keys.
Watch the difference Commas change the information structure; they are not optional decoration around every who-clause.
10
anyone / someone + who + singular verb; those / people + who + plural verb
anyone who / those who
describe a class of people
Situation
You want to welcome everyone meeting a condition.
What you communicate
A who-clause states the condition for that group.
The expression before who sets the group; the clause gives its description.
Anyone who needs help can ask me includes any person meeting that condition. Those who need help means the people who need it. These are relative clauses, not questions about names.
Use singular agreement with anyone or someone: anyone who needs help. Use plural agreement with those or people: those who need help. The choice comes from the expression being described.
He who hesitates is lost illustrates a traditional proverb pattern with he who. In ordinary new sentences, the person who or anyone who is usually an easier neutral choice.
Original example
Anyone who needs a printed copy can collect one at reception.
Watch the difference Use those who for people, not those which, in this ordinary meaning.
03
Shape the reference
Small additions change precision, emotion, or whether identity matters at all. Contractions and possessive forms need separate spelling choices.
11
who’s = who is / who has; whose + noun; who’ll = who will; who’d = who would / who had
who’s / whose
distinguish a contraction from a possessive form
Situation
You hear two forms that sound alike.
What you communicate
The surrounding grammar tells you which spelling is needed.
Who’s expands to who is or auxiliary who has; whose marks possession or association.
Who’s coming? means Who is coming? Who’s finished the report? means Who has finished the report? In the second example, has is an auxiliary before a past participle.
Whose keys are these? asks who the keys belong to. In the neighbour whose keys I found, whose links the neighbour to the keys. Whose has no apostrophe.
Other contractions include who’ll for who will and who’d for who would or who had. Compare Who’d like tea? with Who’d already left? Expand the contraction before deciding what grammar follows.
Original example
Who’s found the keys, and whose keys are they?
Watch the difference Test who’s by expanding it. If who is or who has does not fit, an apostrophe is probably wrong.
12
who else + subject-question verb phrase; who else + auxiliary + subject + verb
Who else?
ask about additional or alternative people
Situation
You know that one person is coming.
What you communicate
You ask whether other people are coming too.
Else adds “other” or “additional”; it follows who.
Who else is coming? asks about people besides those already mentioned. Who else can we ask? can seek an alternative person when the first person cannot help.
Else does not replace the normal question grammar: Who else called? is a subject question; Who else did you call? is an object question. The basic difference remains.
Exactly can instead request precision: Who exactly did you call? It does not mean “which additional person.”
Original example
I know Ben is coming. Who else have you invited?
Watch the difference Say Who else…?, not Else who…?, in an ordinary question.
13
who on earth + question clause; emphatic whoever + question clause
Who on earth…?
make an identity question emphatic
Situation
You find an unexpected change and are surprised.
What you communicate
You ask the identity question with extra emotion.
On earth adds surprise or frustration; it does not identify a location.
Who on earth changed the password? is an emphatic version of Who changed the password? The expression often signals surprise, anger, or difficulty imagining an answer.
The extra words do not change the subject/object pattern: Who on earth did you invite? still needs did because you is the subject and who is the object.
Whoever in questions can also emphasize surprise, as in Whoever told you that? This is different from whoever meaning any person who. Neutral who is safer in a polite request where emphasis could sound accusatory.
Original example
Who on earth scheduled a meeting for six in the morning?
Watch the difference On earth is an informal intensifier here, not a request to locate someone on the planet.
14
no matter who + clause, + main clause; whoever + clause
no matter who…
say that someone’s identity will not change the result
Situation
Different people might ask for access.
What you communicate
The same rule will apply to all of them.
No matter removes identity as a condition that could change the outcome.
No matter who asks, we need written permission means the requirement applies regardless of the person asking. The clause does not ask the listener to supply a name.
Whoever asks, we need written permission can express the same “regardless of who” idea. But whoever also forms a noun-like expression: Whoever arrives first can open the room means the person who arrives first.
Do not substitute bare who whenever you mean any person who. Invite whoever you like is a useful neutral model. Dictionaries also record bare-who expressions such as bring who you want; this lesson uses whoever as the general model rather than teaching bare who as freely interchangeable with it.
Original example
No matter who calls, do not share the access code.
Watch the difference No matter who calls is a condition attached to the instruction, not the name of the person receiving it.
04
Read the conversational intention
A who-question can express uncertainty, disagreement, dismissal, or a challenge. Learn these established expressions with their tone; their intention is not supplied by who alone.
15
Who knows?; who can say + embedded question; who’s to say + clause
Who knows? / Who’s to say?
express uncertainty rather than request a name
Situation
Someone asks whether an uncertain plan will work.
What you communicate
You acknowledge that the answer is not known.
The whole question can communicate lack of knowledge instead of searching for an expert.
Who knows? can mean I don’t know; perhaps nobody can be sure. “Will they agree?” “Who knows? We can ask.” The question form leaves the answer open.
Who can say what will happen? similarly presents an uncertain answer. Who’s to say the plan won’t work? keeps a possibility open because nobody can establish the opposite.
These expressions can still be literal in the right context. Who knows the Wi-Fi password? may be a real request for someone who has the information. Read the situation before treating every who-question as rhetorical.
Original example
Who knows? We might finish earlier than expected.
Watch the difference Who’s to say…? contains who is, not the possessive whose.
16
Who cares?; who cares + what / whether-clause
Who cares?
dismiss something as unimportant
Situation
A minor detail is causing unnecessary worry.
What you communicate
You say it should not matter.
The familiar rhetorical question can imply that nobody needs to worry about it.
Who cares? often means That isn’t important rather than Please name someone who cares. “The plates don’t match.” “Who cares? The food is ready.” The intended response is about importance.
The expression is informal and can sound rude or dismissive, especially when the other person is upset. That doesn’t matter to me or I don’t mind can be gentler, depending on the intended meaning.
A literal question remains possible: Who cares for the garden while you’re away? asks which person does that job. Care for also contributes its own meaning there.
Original example
Who cares if the chairs are different colours? There is room for everyone.
Watch the difference Do not use Who cares? as a polite way to ask someone’s preferences; it can reject the concern itself.
17
who says + clause; Who says so?
Who says…?
challenge a statement or supposed rule
Situation
Someone claims an activity is only for a certain group.
What you communicate
You reject that claim or ask what supports it.
The speaker challenges the claim rather than merely requesting its author.
Who says beginners can’t join? pushes back against an opinion or rule. It suggests the speaker does not accept the claim as established.
Who said that? may instead be a literal question about a source, or it may challenge what was said. Tone and context decide. The word who itself does not encode disagreement.
Who’s to say…? focuses on uncertainty or an open possibility. Who says…? is a more direct challenge to a statement.
Original example
Who says we have to wait until Monday? We can start today.
Watch the difference It can sound confrontational. What makes you say that? can be a more open request for reasons.
18
who + be + person + to-infinitive; Who do you think you are?
Who are you to…?
question someone’s right to judge or act
Situation
Someone gives an order without accepted authority.
What you communicate
The speaker challenges that person’s right to give it.
The issue is authority or entitlement, not simply a missing name.
Who are you to decide for everyone? questions the listener’s right to decide. Who am I to judge? turns the pattern inward and can express modesty or reluctance to criticize.
Who do you think you are? can accuse someone of behaving as if they have special status. In this use it is angry or disapproving, rather than a neutral request for a personal description.
These meanings come from the whole construction and situation. Compare the ordinary identity question Who are you? and the opinion question Who do you think called?
Original example
Who am I to tell you how to spend your free time?
Watch the difference Who are you to…? is often hostile. Do not treat it as a routine polite way to check someone’s job title.
19
Look who’s talking!
Look who’s talking!
point out that a critic has the same fault
Situation
A person who is often late criticizes another person for lateness.
What you communicate
You point out the inconsistency.
The expression turns attention back to the critic’s own behaviour.
Look who’s talking! means You do that too, so your criticism is inconsistent. It is an informal comeback and can be playful among friends or sharp in an argument.
It does not normally ask the listener to identify a person who is speaking. Compare literal Look who’s at the door!, which can draw attention to an unexpected visitor.
The full phrase supplies the critical meaning. It cannot be predicted just by combining who with the ordinary meaning of talk.
Original example
“You always leave your desk untidy.” “Look who’s talking!”
Watch the difference Use the expression only when the critic shares the fault; it is not a general reply to any criticism.
20
who needs + noun phrase?
Who needs…?
reject something as unnecessary or unhelpful
Situation
An extra device is being promoted for a simple task.
What you communicate
You say the device is unnecessary.
The rhetorical question rejects the need rather than collecting names.
Who needs another app for this? can mean We don’t need another app. It often expresses impatience or a confident refusal.
The same grammar can ask a genuine question: Who needs a lift home? invites people to identify themselves so that transport can be arranged. Context distinguishes the offer from the dismissal.
The dismissive meaning belongs to the expression in its situation. Who still refers to people, while needs and the context establish what is being rejected.
Original example
Who needs a special timer? My phone can do that.
Watch the difference Do not assume Who needs…? is always rude or rhetorical; it can be an ordinary offer of help.
21
who + be + person + kidding / trying to kid?
Who are you kidding?
reject a claim as unconvincing
Situation
A person makes a claim that seems plainly unrealistic.
What you communicate
The speaker expresses disbelief.
The question challenges the attempted impression rather than asking for a victim’s name.
Who are you kidding? or Who are you trying to kid? suggests that the claim cannot convincingly fool anyone. It is informal and can be insulting.
Who am I kidding? turns the challenge inward: the speaker admits that their own hopeful claim is unrealistic. “I can finish all this tonight. Who am I kidding? It will take days.”
Kid here is a verb connected with deceiving or joking, not the noun meaning child. This expression questions credibility; Look who’s talking! questions a critic’s consistency.
Original example
Who am I kidding? I need at least another week to finish.
Watch the difference Do not use Who are you kidding? as a neutral request for clarification. It already conveys disbelief.
22
know / learn / find out + who’s who; a who’s who of + field
who’s who
understand people’s identities and roles
Situation
You have joined a team and do not know everyone yet.
What you communicate
You learn which person has which name or role.
The repeated who matches people with identities within a group.
Knowing who’s who in a team means understanding the people’s names, roles, or positions. It is useful when joining a workplace, reading a story, or meeting a large family.
A who’s who can also be a book or list about famous people. A guest list described as a who’s who of science contains many well-known people in that field. This noun use is a related established expression.
In who’s who, who’s expands to who is. The whole expression may follow know or learn without becoming a direct question.
Original example
The team chart helped me work out who’s who in the office.
Watch the difference Learning who’s who does not necessarily mean becoming close friends; it concerns recognition and roles.
You refer to that person while leaving the name unspoken.
The identity is shared rather than requested; the speaker deliberately avoids the name.
You-know-who is an informal substitute for a person’s name. I got another message from you-know-who assumes that the listener can identify the sender from shared context. It can sound playful, secretive, or pointed, depending on the situation.
Compare I know who sent it, which states that I have the information, with You-know-who sent it, which uses the whole expression to stand for the sender. The hyphenated expression is not a question.
The diagram’s identity link is useful here, but its empty position does not mean both speakers are ignorant: the name is left unsaid even though the intended person is understood.
Original example
I saved a seat for you-know-who, so please leave it free.
Watch the difference This works only when the listener can work out the intended person. Use a name or a clearer description when the reference would be ambiguous.
Choose by reference, grammar, and tone
Who, what, and which
Who asks about a person’s identity. What do you do? asks about work or activity; What is she like? asks for a description. Which person or which of you makes a selection explicit. Do not put who directly before a noun as if it were which.
People are the main reference, not an absolute biological rule
Use who for people and which or that for ordinary objects. Who also occurs for animals treated as individuals and for groups understood as people. Personification and literary extensions exist; they do not make who a general substitute for which.
Follow the role inside the clause
Who is the usual subject form and also the everyday object form. Whom is the formal object alternative, especially immediately after a fronted preposition; it is not a more elegant subject form. Whose expresses possession or association. After a quantifier, formal relatives use of whom: two colleagues, both of whom work remotely.
Scope and parts of speech
This lesson covers modern interrogative and relative who and selected conversational expressions. Some dictionaries label embedded-question who a conjunction; others group it with the pronoun. The construction matters more than that label. Bare indefinite-relative who, historical expressions, and uppercase WHO, the organization abbreviation, are not expanded into separate lessons.
Find the person position and the intention
Choose the sentence or interpretation that fits the situation.
1. Someone sent the note. You want to know the sender. Which question fits?
2. Ask politely for the visitor’s identity. Which form keeps the correct inner word order?
3. Which sentence correctly identifies the person through your earlier call?
4. Ask who owns a coat. Which form fits?
5. Maya is already identified; you add that she lives nearby. Which written form fits?
6. An often-late colleague criticizes you for being late. What does Look who’s talking! convey?
7. No matter who asks, we need written permission. What does this mean?
Sources and teaching notes
The sources below support the usage inventory. Explanations and examples are original; the diagram is a teaching interpretation. Dictionary labels and groupings sometimes differ.
The diagram models a reference relation; it does not represent a picture shared by every native speaker.